The Apocalyptic Difference of Jordan Wood and David Bentley Hart

In some sense all Christians, in as much as they believe in revelation are apocalyptic, but the word takes on a particular emphasis in conjunction with the Apostle Paul (along with other New Testament writers). Rather than a slow unfolding of salvation in history (salvation history) New Testament scholars like Louis Martyn, emphasize the disjunction and difference brought about by Christ (in Paul’s explanation). There is new creation, new birth, a new human subject, a transformed mind. This new world order contains a new epistemology, which both in Galatians and Corinthians, is contrasted with a fleshly way of knowing: “Therefore from now on we recognize no one by the flesh; even though we have known Christ by the flesh, yet now we know Him in this way no longer. Therefore if anyone is in Christ, this person is a new creation; the old things passed away; behold, new things have come” (2 Corinthians 5:16-17). Paul is describing an apocalypse (a fulness of revelation) already realized in Christ. We are to enact this apocalyptic difference, dying and rising now in baptism, being transformed in our mind, in what we can call psychic conversion. There is a traceable diagnosis of a disease, a lie, a misorientation, that has a clear cure and resolution. Some, so called apocalyptic theologians, might acknowledge this might happen in the future, but it has not clearly unfolded from the past into the present, or from point of the cross and the incarnation to my encounter with Christ. The focus is on a not yet, that is slowly being realized in a future now. On the other hand, those who subscribe to a realized apocalyptic, focus on the possibilities of the now, upon the new order ushered in by Christ. Salvation is to be “worked out” in realizing, or making actual, this apocalyptic difference in the present.

Though David Hart and Jordan Wood would both consider themselves apocalyptic theologians, this takes on a contrasting emphasis that pertains to much of their theology, with Hart focused on a future horizon (the not yet, though this is too simple) and Jordan focused on the reality of the historical Christ (now). Hart frames the apocalypse as a teleological unveiling of a timeless, analogical truth, whereas Wood frames it as a Christological event in which Christ becomes “all in all” through the incarnation and hypostatic synthesis. This apocalyptic difference seems to lend a different emphasis throughout. Jordan describes conversion, not on the basis of an already shared analogical participation (shared and realized in Neoplatonism and the best Hindu and Buddhist traditions, according to Hart) but as specific to Christ and accomplished singularly and uniquely through Christ. He is continuing in the apocalyptic tradition of Maximus to accentuate the world of difference Christ makes in his specific person and work.

This means there is passage from a “false incarnation,” a developing possibility for evil, a lie or epistemological error gripping humanity and then clear recognition of Christ’s exposure of this deception and how it is the world is made new and complete in Christ. The most immediate implication is that this apocalyptic picture of conversion creates the basis for describing the absence of God in the human subject, and the apocalyptic difference (best characterized in the contrast between Romans 7 and 8). Hart’s analogical perennialism, presumes there is a given understanding (knowledge of God as creator and law giver) available to all persons (whose capacity for reason remains largely intact in spite of sin, though he does speak of ignorance) and that salvation does not pertain to rooting out the source of this epistemological falsehood. That is, in Paul, the principalities and powers, or in John the cosmos, is deluded and in darkness and this lie takes on an animate force in sin.

Jordan, in attempting to clarify his perception of the disagreement with Hart, focuses on the issue of nature and grace as worked out by Maximus the Confessor.[1] Maximus provides two pictures of this relationship, which on the surface may appear contradictory, but which are reconciled in Christ. Maximus is, “on the one hand very clear, like in stark, stark terms, that grace is in no way anticipated by nature.” There is an “aporia of grace.” Grace is an unmerited transcendent gift which is separate from nature in the first instance, but which nonetheless is a synergistic, cooperative human achievement through Christ in the second instance. As Maximus puts it in letter 9, “For the aim of the Giver of the commandments was to liberate humanity from the world and nature.” In stark terms, grace is “in no way anticipated by nature” (Wood cites Ambiguum 21 and Opusculum 1). Nothing in human nature already leads to deifying grace. Otherwise, why call it ecstasy, which, following Dionysius, means going out of one’s nature to become something it isn’t? “Ecstasy is precisely per Dionysius going out of one’s nature to become something it isn’t.” Maximus keeps created and uncreated distinct, precisely to show that the union is ecstatic, loving and interpersonal. 

Jordan points out, “He also claims that we have the ‘power’ in our nature to seek God and to ‘attain salvation,’ so that in acquiring virtue we move from being God’s image to being his ‘likeness,’ ‘receiving from God to be God’ by ‘natural movement.’”[2] Though Maximus says grace is in no way anticipated by nature, he also says the power that deified Melchizedek is in everyone and everything. Maximus reads Melchizedek’s being “without generation” to mean that he literally becomes uncreated (Ambiguum 10). Then he adds: do not think you cannot be a Melchizedek, because the same power (dynamis) that deifies him “is in everyone and in all things.”

So, nature and grace pose the same problem as Christ’s two natures, and the answer is the same: the two are one only in a person, never on the level of nature or definition, where forcing them together destroys one or both, or makes a third thing. On one hand grace seems almost wholly separate from nature, and on the other it seems everywhere, almost native to all nature. A Christological understanding of creation explains this, and even predicts it. The key is that grace is not “some third thing” between God and the world, a boost or an injection: “It is God.” God comes to us in the grace shed through Jesus Christ.

Hart (in You Are Gods) wants to say we are by nature God, reasoning that the end of a thing tells you what it always was. Our end is deification (“You are gods,” Jesus quoting the Psalm), so it must lie in us from our origin, from birth, which is where the Latin natura comes from. The problem is nature can mean a thing’s essence, its kind, which fixes the kind of perfection it can have (for Aristotle, contemplation for rational beings), or it can mean something looser and more phenomenological: what is in you from your origin to become.  We are “by our very origin to become God”, but just as truly, from our origin we were never simply human in that we were made for divinity. It does not mean that being human, as such, is to be divine. If it did, why would Christ need two natures? Wood suspects Hart makes a phenomenological point that sometimes slides into metaphysics, and that is the equivocation he wants to avoid. If being human simply leads to being God, why seven hundred years of controversy (Arianism, the debates over one energy and one nature, Chalcedon)? Even Aristotle, in Book 10 of the Nicomachean Ethics, could not see how we might be both human and divine. From our origin we are “to become God,” but that means we were never simply human.

Divinization grows from an event, a God-Man dying on a cross, and not from abstract opposites needing a principle to join them. Christ is not an exception to a rule, nor a rule with instances, but a person. We encounter God, and participate in God through this person. “God alone can make gods.” As Maximus states it in Question 60 (to Thalassius): the recapitulation of all things in God is God. “He is so gracious that He becomes the very act of His own grace, and He is that.” If so, joining nature and grace is the same problem as joining Christ’s two natures, and Maximus solves both the same way. You don’t bring them together on the level of essence or definition, where you would destroy one or both. You bring them together only on the level of the person. Nature and grace meet the way God and man meet in Christ: in one person. This is an apocalyptic synthesis that does not simply look to the end, but it is the enactment of the end. It is not a metaphysical or theoretical possibility that can be predicted beforehand, but can only be understood and realized in Christ. Nobody started with an abstract problem about divinity and humanity and then tried to “shove them together.” A God-Man died on the cross, and from that event came the question: how is this possible, is he really God? The event gives rise to the question and to a deeper logic, and not the other way round. There is no “principle” to solve abstract opposites: “opposites can’t be reconciled on the very grounds by which they are opposite.” Thus the resolution is in the person of Christ and is personal. There is not a metaphysical or theoretical, but a personal resolution.  “Christ is the resolution.” The cross came first and the puzzle came after. In Christ we meet God and the possibility of entering into divinity is opened to us.

Jordan, along with Maximus, I would characterize as an apocalyptic theologian on the order of Louis Martyn, in that in coming to Christ one is not simply becoming who they innately already are, though the were made for knowing and participating in God. There is a profound emptiness, an immaturity, a false orientation, or a lie at work, which can be attributed to demonic deception, the powers, misorientation to the law. It may be in imagining nature is adequate unto itself, or imagining law is the means to God (a principle, a theory, a nature) even imagining that the natural is naturally given to participating in divinity. The only way to God is through God in Christ. We all pass through a false beginning, or one that is misdirected, as exposed by and subject to shame (as I have extensively described it). This means the beginning of creation (the true beginning in Christ) is in the middle of history. As John Behr notes: “According to The Martyrology of Jerome, ‘On March 25, our Lord Jesus Christ was crucified, conceived, and the world was made.’”[3] In the false beginning the creature is necessarily brought into existence involuntarily, but in Christ all voluntarily give assent to be born into life “in and as Christ” entailing the other Maximian formula, “creation is incarnation.”  Now all voluntarily give “assent to be born into life in and as Christ, entailing that creation is indeed Incarnation.”[4] Creation is not naturally incarnation, but this occurs only in Christ.

In this the theology of Maximus and Jordan, at least in its initial phase fits with the understanding of the human subject, as described by Slavoj Zizek’s reading of Romans 7. For Zizek, Paul is describing the complete human (or Christian), without the Spirit, without the Son, without the Holy Spirit, and most importantly without the obscene superego-God. Here is natural man, split, driven and obsessed by death and law, and ultimately grounded in a lie. This is as good as it gets for natural man. The move from chapter 7 to chapter 8 is an apocalyptic remaking of the person, now found in Christ, ordered and living by the Spirit, and living in relationship with God as Father. Maximus describes this as the relation between potentiality and actuality:

The mode of our spiritual birth from God is twofold. The first bestows on those born in God the entire grace of adoption, which is entirely present in potential; the second ushers in this grace as entirely present in actuality, transforming voluntarily the entire free choice of the one being born so that it conforms to the God who gives birth. The first possesses this grace in potential according to faith alone; the second, in addition to faith, realizes on the level of knowledge the active, most divine likeness of the God who is known in the one who knows Him. In those whom the first mode of birth is observed, it happens that—because the disposition of their will has not yet been fully extracted from its passionate fixation on the flesh, and because they have not been completely imbued by the Spirit with active participation in the divine mysteries that have taken place—it happens, I say, that their inclination to sin is never very far away for the simple reason that they continue to will it.[5]

The first birth, through Christ, is no longer simply a form of bondage but an opening to a second birth in the Spirit. Though bodily and Spiritual birth may appear as distinct temporal moments, this division is due to sin or the human attempt to make themselves (in Freudian terms to be their own father). For Maximus, there is though, an inevitable passing through these two moments as the first birth is the means to the second birth.

In this way God joined together in me the principle of my being and the principle of my well-being, and He closed the division and distance between them that I had opened up, and through them He wisely drew’ me to the principle of eternal being, according to which man is no longer subject to carrying or being carried along, since the sequence of visible realities in motion will reach its end in the great and general resurrection. . .[6]

There is a definitive passage from being to well being, a passage which sin aggravates and which Christ closes. Where Hart acknowledges Christ reveals the eternal truth of God-world unity which is always metaphysically true, for Maximus (and Jordan) the Incarnation is the ontological realization of the fulness of being and creation (the passage from “being” to “well being,” or the movement from “image” to “likeness”). History and creation are literally assumed into the person of the Logos, meaning the end retroactively causes the beginning (in Maximus’ terms the end is in the beginning and the beginning is in the end). The difference between God and man, nature and grace, eternity and time, are overcome in the identity of Christ (eternally the case), and this is the identity to be put on in the now and not a delayed not yet.


[1] http://podcast.forgingploughshares.org/e/jordan-daniel-wood-on-his-departure-from-david-bentley-hart/ Thank you to Jim Monroe for providing a transcript and summary of the podcast.

[2] Jordan Wood, “Against Nature?” from Words In Flesh, Oct 29, 2023.

[3] This is John in Behr’s summary in the Foreword to the book, Jordan Daniel Wood, The Whole Mystery of Christ (pp. ix). University of Notre Dame Press. Kindle Edition.

[4] Ibid.

[5] St. Maximus the Confessor, On Difficulties In Sacred Scripture: The Responses to Thalassios; Translated by Fr. Maximos Constas, (Washington D. C.: The Catholic University of America Press) 6.2.

[6] Maximus the Confessor, The Ambigua, Volume 2, trans. Nicholas Constas (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2014)  42.32.